Is a VPN Safe? The Risks and How to Check a Provider
A reputable VPN is safe to use and legal in most countries. Learn what the provider sees, what audits and real cases show, and why free apps are risky.
A VPN from a reputable provider is safe to use, and using one is legal in most countries. The risk lies with the provider, because it now sees what your internet provider used to see. Choose one with an audited no-logs policy, an app that keeps traffic inside the tunnel and a record you can check.
What the provider can see
Once the VPN is on, your Wi-Fi network and internet provider see only encrypted traffic to one server. The VPN company takes their place in the middle. The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) warns that installing a VPN app gives it “permission to intercept all of your internet traffic”.
Even on sites that use HTTPS, the encryption behind your browser’s lock icon, the provider can see three things:
- Your real IP address, which points to your home or phone network and your rough location.
- The sites and services you reach, and when, because its servers answer the lookups that turn site names into addresses.
- How much data you move, down to the size of the files you download.
HTTPS still hides the pages you read, your passwords and your messages. The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), a digital rights group, notes that what a VPN hides from your internet provider is “all visible to the VPN provider”. Whether a VPN is safe therefore depends on what the company keeps, who can force it to hand that over and whether its apps leak.
No-logs promises and the audits that test them
All twelve providers we track promise not to log what you do online. What matters is whether an outside firm such as Deloitte, KPMG or Securitum has checked the servers and procedures against the policy. The table gives each provider’s newest audit of its logging and how many it has had.
| Provider | Latest no-logs audit | No-logs audits on record |
|---|---|---|
| CyberGhost | 2025, Deloitte Audit Romania | 3 |
| ExpressVPN | 2025, KPMG | 4 |
| hide.me | 2024, Securitum | 2 |
| IPVanish | 2026, Schellman Compliance, LLC | 3 |
| IVPN | 2019, Cure53 | 1 |
| Mullvad VPN | 2022, Assured AB | 1 |
| NordVPN | 2025, Deloitte Audit Lithuania | 6 |
| PrivadoVPN | None | 0 |
| Private Internet Access | 2025, Deloitte Audit Romania | 3 |
| Proton VPN | 2026, Securitum | 5 |
| Surfshark | 2026, KPMG Baltics, UAB and KPMG AB | 3 |
| Windscribe | None | 0 |
Ten of the twelve have had at least one. NordVPN has had six since 2018 and Proton VPN one a year since 2022, while IVPN’s only no-logs audit dates from 2019. Windscribe and PrivadoVPN have never had their logging audited.
An audit covers only the days the auditor looked. The EFF warns that “there’s no certainty that the practices aren’t changed after the audit, especially if compelled to do so by a government”. Recent reports matter most, and our no-logs explainer shows what each kind of log can reveal.
What real cases have shown
Audits are planned, so stronger evidence comes from events a provider did not choose: a police search, a court order or a break-in.
When the authorities asked
Private Internet Access, a US company, has had its no-logs claim tested twice. A 2016 FBI subpoena got only one answer: the addresses belonged to a cluster of its servers on the US East Coast. At a 2018 hacking trial, its top lawyer testified that it keeps no activity logs.
Mullvad’s test came in April 2023, when Swedish police searched its Gothenburg office for computers holding customer data. No such data existed, so the officers left without taking anything.
A promise that failed
In 2016, under its previous owner Highwinds, IPVanish gave US Homeland Security a subscriber’s name, email address, real IP address and connection times. It did so while advertising that it kept no logs. StackPath, which bought the service in 2017, said it found no logs or logging systems.
Now owned by Ziff Davis, IPVanish has passed three no-logs audits since 2022. The timeline sets its record beside that of Private Internet Access.
Independent audits and incidents
IPVanish
-
Schellman Compliance, LLC checked the no-logs policy. Source
-
Schellman Compliance, LLC checked the no-logs policy. Source
-
Leviathan Security Group checked the no-logs policy. Source
-
Incident. Under a previous owner, IPVanish gave US investigators a user's details and connection times despite a no-logs promise. Source
Private Internet Access
-
Deloitte Audit Romania checked the no-logs policy and the server infrastructure. Source
-
Deloitte Audit Romania checked the no-logs policy and the server infrastructure. Source
-
Deloitte Audit Romania checked the no-logs policy and the server infrastructure. Source
-
Incident. In a US hacking trial, PIA testified that it keeps no activity logs and could not identify the user. Source
-
Incident. Russian authorities seized several PIA servers, and PIA then pulled all of its servers out of Russia. Source
-
Incident. An FBI subpoena asked for user logs, and PIA could only name the server cluster the addresses belonged to. Source
Audits by outside firms, and incidents from public reports. Checked between 31 Oct and 7 Nov 2026. A red dot marks an incident.
Break-ins and bugs
Break-ins and software bugs are a separate risk, and large providers have had both:
- An intruder got into a NordVPN server in Finland in March 2018 through a remote-management account the data center had added. NordVPN says the server held no activity logs, and it made the break-in public 19 months later.
- Authorities in Ukraine seized two Windscribe servers in June 2021 whose unencrypted disks held a server certificate and its private key. Windscribe replaced its certificates and moved every server to RAM-only operation, which keeps nothing after a restart.
- In 2024 one split-tunneling mode in ExpressVPN’s Windows app sent some DNS requests outside the tunnel, usually to the user’s internet provider, until ExpressVPN switched the feature off and fixed it.
Each company published what happened and changed something as a result.
Free VPNs and apps from unknown developers
Running a VPN costs money, so a free one is paid for some other way. In the FTC’s words, “Many VPN apps are free because they sell advertising within the app, or because they share your information with (or redirect your traffic through) third parties.” Three findings show where that can lead:
- Data shared despite a privacy pitch. Facebook’s free Onavo Protect app was promoted as a way to keep your data safe. Australia’s consumer regulator says records of the apps people used went to Meta in anonymized form for market research, and in 2023 a court ordered two Meta subsidiaries to pay A$10 million each.
- Malware bundled with free VPNs. In May 2024 the FBI and two other US agencies warned that free VPN apps packaged with pirated games and software had silently installed a backdoor. The resulting network spanned more than 19 million compromised IP addresses, and criminals used it for bomb threats, fraud and identity theft.
- Leaky apps full of trackers. A peer-reviewed 2016 study of 283 free Android VPN apps found that 18% did not encrypt traffic and 75% carried third-party tracking code. At least one antivirus engine flagged 38% of them, though only 4% were flagged by more than five.
Free plans from established providers are a different matter. Proton VPN, hide.me, Windscribe and PrivadoVPN all offer one, but only Proton VPN and hide.me have had their logging audited. Our reviews of the Proton VPN and Windscribe free plans list their limits.
Leaks and the kill switch
A leak happens when some of your traffic slips outside the encrypted tunnel, so your internet provider or a website sees what the VPN should hide. The table shows the three common kinds and how to check for each.
| Leak | What escapes the tunnel | What it can give away | How to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| DNS | The lookups that turn site names into addresses | The sites you visit, to your internet provider | Keep the app’s DNS leak protection on, because our tools cannot test DNS yet |
| IPv6 | Traffic to sites that use the newer address format | Your real IPv6 address, to those sites | Our IPv6 leak test |
| WebRTC | The browser feature behind video calls | Your real IP address, to the page you are on | Our WebRTC leak test |
Leaks were the norm in the 2016 Android study, where about 84% of the apps sent IPv6 traffic outside the tunnel and 66% did the same with DNS lookups. Established providers slip too, as ExpressVPN’s bug shows.
All twelve providers we track run their own DNS servers and say their apps prevent DNS leaks. CyberGhost, ExpressVPN, IPVanish, Private Internet Access and Surfshark block IPv6 while you are connected, and the other five can carry it inside the tunnel. NordVPN says only that it does not support IPv6 yet, and PrivadoVPN claims IPv6 leak protection without saying how, so the IPv6 test matters most for them.
A WebRTC leak comes from your browser, not the VPN app. The IETF, which writes internet standards, notes that with a split-tunnel VPN, WebRTC “can discover not only the public address for the VPN, but also the ISP public address over which the VPN is running”.
The kill switch
A kill switch blocks all traffic when the tunnel drops, so your apps cannot fall back to your normal connection. Every provider we track has one on desktop, and all except IVPN document one for current phones. Mullvad’s cannot be turned off and ExpressVPN’s starts switched on, but check the setting in any app you install. Our kill switch explainer shows how to test it.
When the network itself is hostile
A flaw published in May 2024, CVE-2024-3661, lets an attacker on the same local network, such as public Wi-Fi, rewrite your device’s routes. VPN apps that rely on those routes then “leak traffic over the physical interface”. The US National Vulnerability Database rates it high severity. Mullvad said that month that the firewall rules in its desktop apps stop the attacker from reading the traffic.
Where the company is based
Jurisdiction, the country whose laws a provider must follow, decides which courts and agencies can make it hand over data. The table shows each provider’s home country, intelligence alliance and owner.
| Provider | Based in | Intelligence alliance | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| CyberGhost | Romania | None | CyberGhost S.R.L. (Kape Technologies) |
| ExpressVPN | British Virgin Islands | None | Express Technologies Ltd. (Kape Technologies) |
| hide.me | Malaysia | None | eVenture Ltd. |
| IPVanish | United States | Five Eyes | Ziff Davis, Inc. (Ziff Davis) |
| IVPN | Gibraltar | None | IVPN Limited |
| Mullvad VPN | Sweden | Fourteen Eyes | Mullvad VPN AB |
| NordVPN | Panama | None | nordvpn S.A. (Nord Security) |
| PrivadoVPN | Iceland | None | Privado Networks ehf |
| Private Internet Access | United States | Five Eyes | Private Internet Access, Inc. (Kape Technologies) |
| Proton VPN | Switzerland | None | Proton AG |
| Surfshark | Netherlands | Nine Eyes | Surfshark B.V. (Nord Security) |
| Windscribe | Canada | Five Eyes | Windscribe Limited |
What a company keeps matters more than its address. Mullvad is based in Sweden, a member of the Fourteen Eyes intelligence-sharing group, yet the police found nothing to take. NordVPN is based in Panama, outside every alliance, but a binding warrant from Panama’s prosecutor in October 2024 still made it hand over the user data it held. Under its policy, that means account details such as an email address.
The owner matters too, since IPVanish failed under an earlier one. Our guide to the Five, Nine and Fourteen Eyes explains what alliance membership does and does not mean.
Where using a VPN is restricted
Using a VPN is legal in the UK, the US, Australia and most other countries, but a few restrict it. The UK government’s travel advice says China’s cybersecurity laws require online products and services, VPNs included, to be licensed by the Chinese government. For Turkmenistan it is blunter: “VPNs are illegal in Turkmenistan and are usually blocked as soon as the authorities identify them.”
Where a VPN is legal, the law still applies to what you do through it. Before you travel, read our China guide for the fines its rules allow, or the laws hub for the other countries we track.
Not legal advice. This page summarizes public laws, regulations and official statements as of the date shown, with sources. Laws change and enforcement varies. If you use a VPN to break the law or a service's terms, that is your responsibility. Check local rules before you rely on anything here.
A safety checklist
Run through these checks before you trust a VPN with your traffic:
- A recent audit. An outside firm has checked the provider’s logging in the last two years.
- A public record. Its review and transparency report list incidents and legal requests, and show how quickly it disclosed them.
- A developer you can name. Skip free apps from companies you cannot identify, and check the permissions an app asks for.
- Open code, ideally. IVPN, Mullvad, Private Internet Access and Proton VPN publish the code of all their apps, so outside experts can inspect it.
- A kill switch that is on, checked in the app’s settings.
- No leaks. Run our VPN check after you install the app and after major updates.
- The local law, checked before you travel.
We have not yet tested speed, streaming or leaks in our own lab. Each provider fact here comes from the provider’s own pages, its audit reports or the sources listed below. For providers that pass most of these checks, see our best VPNs for privacy.
Related
Frequently asked questions
Is it safe to use a VPN?
Are free VPNs safe?
Can my VPN provider see what I do online?
Is it legal to use a VPN?
Can a VPN app contain malware?
How do I know if my VPN is leaking?
Sources
- 1. US Federal Trade Commission business blog: In the market for a VPN app? (Andrea Arias, February 2018) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 2. EFF Surveillance Self-Defense: Choosing the VPN That's Right for You (last reviewed July 2026) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 3. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, alert I-052924-PSA: Guidance on the 911 S5 Residential Proxy Service (May 2024) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 4. ACCC: $20m penalty for Meta companies for conduct liable to mislead consumers about use of their data (July 2023) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 5. Ikram, Vallina-Rodriguez, Seneviratne, Kaafar and Paxson: An Analysis of the Privacy and Security Risks of Android VPN Permission-enabled Apps (ACM IMC 2016) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 6. IETF RFC 8828: WebRTC IP Address Handling Requirements (January 2021) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 7. NIST National Vulnerability Database: CVE-2024-3661 (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 8. Mullvad blog: Evaluating the impact of TunnelVision (May 2024) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 9. UK Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office: China travel advice, safety and security (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 10. UK Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office: Turkmenistan travel advice, safety and security (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 11. TorrentFreak: VPN Provider's No-Logging Claims Tested in FBI Case (March 2016) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 12. TorrentFreak: Private Internet Access' 'No-Logging' Claims Proven True Again in Court (June 2018) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 13. TorrentFreak: IPVanish 'No-Logging' VPN Led Homeland Security to Comcast User (May 2018) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 14. Mullvad blog: Mullvad VPN was subject to a search warrant. Customer data not compromised (April 2023) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 15. NordVPN blog: NordVPN introduces transparency reports (October 2024 warrant) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 16. NordVPN blog: Why the NordVPN network is safe after a third-party provider breach (October 2019) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 17. Windscribe blog: OpenVPN Security Improvements and Changes (July 2021) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
- 18. ExpressVPN blog: After a tip, ExpressVPN acts swiftly to protect customers (split tunneling DNS fix, February 2024) (accessed 17 Nov 2026)
Changelog
- First published.